But if you want to become really proficient shooting this gun,the .38/.357 combo is the way you want to go. (Pistols which have hammers sometimes feel a little better.) 357 Magnum . Stainless steel contains chromium, which resists the leeching, and this makes stainless a better gun steel, in my opinion. 1. model 19, The fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead. Inadvertent? This was not a serious issue with the .38 Special +P loads. After logging in you can close it and return to this page. Why not bring back the Model 28? Possible causes include the use of ammunition that is incompatible with the revolver. I dont know that I will indeed make it my EDC but I ordered a high quality 5 .357 last month to explore the idea. Failure to Fire. The Model 19 was also offered in nickel finish. The variety in Smith & Wesson's catalog has only increased throughout the years from the little all steel Model 36 and 60 to the latest alloy framed lightweights like the 637 and 642. Its just about perfect for personal protection, and it makes a darn good trail gun, too. Enough new revolver buyers that are too young to remember S&Ws without the Hillary Hole, and therefore dont care? Over time, using the .357 Magnum load, the temperature and pressure caused by these rounds will erode, cut into, and weaken the frame of the gun. Le/Mil Only. It just points beautifully and with all that real estate in my palm, I found it very easy to hold the gun steady. Then I got a snubby Model 19 to shoot the snubby matches. Later, Jordan became an outdoor writer and wrote for several gun magazines, including Shooting Times. Accuracy was substandard compared to my older Smiths as well. Daily carry requires a good holster. I have shot a model 66 with the new shrouded barrel and the lock. It also featured a fully shrouded ejection rod, a heavy barrel profile, a Baughman ramped front sight, and a fully micrometer adjustable rear sight. I qualify with my 2 model 19 at 50 yards and have much tighter groups than that 66 at 25 yards. Usually 1 @ 25 and sub 2 @ 50. You can also stretch the topstrap, such that the window changes in dimension. Le/Mil Only. I DO realize theres some cost savings, but is it really worth it? To our rather jaded eyes, the traditional Masterpiece guns, without the under-lug, are how a Smith & Wesson revolver should look and the Classic is Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 19 Carry comp, .357 Mag. Ruger LCP vs Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" Ruger LCP. S&W made some great revolvers decades ago, but the model 19 while having a great fit would crack forcing cones. I initially used S&W grips for a .38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little small for good control. Ive heard similar statements in the TTAG comment section and it seems to be a popular myth running around many forums. Smith & Wesson TRR8, 5.0 Barrel, 357 Magnum . The flat part of your forcing cone is normal for this revolver and is one of the reasons the guns fail when one puts a steady diet of .357s through their guns. Hope this area was strengthened in the new model? . Ive only ever owned one revolver, and I regret letting it go. The .357 is still a righteous self defense round. It was a 4 inch blued model 19 the had Idaho State Police on the side of it. Aluminum alloy frame and cylinder Stainless steel barrel XS Sights White Dot front sight In 1955 the .357 Magnum version was first offered. breadcrumb. One thing that struck me was that you were disappointed with all sub 2 groups from 25yds from just a bag even. I never said the gun was slow, I said I was slow with it. From what Ive seen it seems that vented and non vented barrels are a wash in mid length barrels (a 5 Coonan generates velocities similar to a 5 revo lver) but the longer the bullet stays in the barrel the more is lost out the gap, so snubbies dont lose as much. I had a -3 round butt that I couldnt shoot worth a darn. That said, Berettas are what you show your freinds, Glocks are what you show your enemies! I noticed the other night, if I pull back on the cylinder, just a tad, it open as smooth as silk every time. YOU CANNOT BEAT THE MODEL-19-3. Excellent - 95%+ condition with or without box. They are all right for just fooling around, and I wouldnt want to see that changed. Side Refine Panel. It was less than $200 and worth twice that. Its failure due to the lock would not get me killed. The only complaint I had was knoxing the site out of line getting in and out on the stwering wheel off the Patrol Car, and the grip size, which was too big for my hands, but was corrected when I went to Firearms Instructor School, with Hogue rubber groves grips. MIM is a mature production process and an excellent way to produce complex metal parts at lower cost. On a S&W, thats 0.002. And their 4 DASA with exposed trigger is a very comparable choice for anyone interested in the current 4 Model 19 for target shooting or home defense at that barrel length. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic, 4.25" Barrel, 357 Magnum, Blued . Something that pretty doesnt even have to work. The L frame 586s make great guns for duty and walking around the woods and I use my 4 586 for just that. Finish:factory blued steel But I felt like the Smith & Wesson Model 19 could do better. You have some tough standards!:-). Shooting and discussing the new S&W Model 19 Classic. Notice how heavy the trigger pull was compared to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs. Ruger Lcp . The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. The triggers fingerpiece is smooth and measures 0.38 inch wide. Loved the article JW. I love the 19 more than anything and prize them, evwn over my new Sig P226, Mt25 Romeo, I will pick up next week when I get back home from a cruise. Its a beautiful gun, much more refined than the Ruger Security-Six I have from the same era. JWT makes a point regarding 1 7/8 .357s vs. 9mm +Ps. Hellstrom was the president of S&W at the time, and Jordan was famous for many reasons, including serving in the U.S. Border Patrol for 29 years and then touring the country for 11 years as a spokesman for the NRA, during which he performed trick-shooting exhibitions. It would be hard to find a police department in this country which didn't issue or authorize some version of the Model 19 at some point in its history. The only candidates to replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the same caliber from the S&W Performance Center. Smith & Wesson Model 66, 4.25" Barrel, 357 Magnum . Add to Wish List. I ordered the 4.25-inch-barreled Classic revolver for my shooting review. They both also use the full diameter forcing cone which removes the weak link of a notched cone for cyl clearance creating early cracked forcing cones. My ugly Glocks sit at my bedside. Have shot the .357 full loads and I am NOT Impressed with the OVER the TOP Recoil! The Classic 19 is a great addition to the Smith & Wesson line. The gun has gone by many names; the Outdoorsman, K-22, and Masterpiece (with Target, Combat and other variations), always delivering spot-on performance no matter the variation or the name. Does this mean the steel guns arent tough, and cant take magnum loads. Transitioning from one target to the next is fast; the 39oz revolver moves remarkably well for a .357 Magnum. I would expect that anyone with even a fundamental grasp on English would not have read my sentence on the cycle of the 29s cylinder as the notion that once the trigger is touched, the cylinder just spins on while firing, as you apparently have. The front sight wanders around too much for me to do better. Be patient and look for a nice example of both, and hang onto them. I dont believe you need all that heavy frame on your .357 you got now. [Jordan was referring to S&Ws large N-Frame.] The K-Frame Model 19 is iconic, and Im pleased that its back in production. In a day where 4-6 barrel revolvers were found in duty holsters. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. Thats what new gun owners want. An experienced smith fixed it for a few bucks. I still love all of the Smith K frames and the L frames are a close second. It averaged 2.69 inches for five, five-shot groups. End shake? Ive never cleaned a gun Ive reviewed before before, but I felt duty bound to put this one back in same shape in which I got it. But when you despise the Hillary Hole that makes it a lot easier to consider a Kimber instead. The .357 still has an edge but not by much. If they lose that damn internal-lock, Ill consider them again, but not until. Smith has also installed a ball/detent crane lock, and of course, the new 19 has the obligatory key lock. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Its an attractive gun, still sporting the original checkered walnut grips with round S&W medallion, and a 6 barrel (introduced in 1963). I thought that aspect was improved with a thicker forcing cone. JHP. Sounds like you pulled out all the stops for a comprehensive review Jon. In the meantime, give the Model 19 Classic a look. If the pistol has a striker, you cannot feel anything as you pull the trigger other than taking up the often considerable slack and spring tension. People who load their own should be aware that the worries about the flame-cut of the topstrap is only one issue with stout loads. Open the cylinder and check to see if the extractor rod has come slightly unscrewed? You can also buy lighter rebound springs for the S&W. Give that .357 more room to run and its got a lot more power than the 9mm. The second significant difference is that the diameter of the barrel is thicker than the older guns. http://ruger.com/products/gp100/specSheets/1740.html, shoot range sessions with .38 specials, carry .357 Magnums for hunting and self-defense., And watch the bullet sail right over the deers back because the .38 specials are going to hit 8 inches higher than the .357 magnum rounds. The old 19 is still more elegant, the new model must be taken for what it is, an unfaithful copy and a different revolver. The .357 Magnum just cant burn all that powder in such a short barrel. Smith & Wesson. I CURRENTLY OWN A 6 AND A 4 MODELS, BOTH BLUE IN PERFECT CONDITION ,ALMOST NIB. The rear sight is the classic micrometer adjustable blade but lacks a white outline rear sight. But there is nothing obligatory about the Lawyer Lock particularly in law. and of course, the new 19 has the obligatory key lock and that is the first thing going in the trash bin before I even shoot it! In my eyes, it's one of the sexiest revolvers ever made. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It made me realize how good I could actually shoot a pistol. Just clean it up with a ScotchBrite pad. Most of . My shooter is a 19-3, and my show off is a 19-4 (Detroit Police 1978 Commemorative) which has never been fired. The front sight is a pinned ramp with a retro red ramp insert. The Model 19 Classic is a great addition to the Smith & Wesson line and will hopefully renew the interest in wheelguns for new shooters. A bit wary if its a one of QC issue or something consistent in this line? The most accurate .357 Magnum load was the Winchester 125-grain Defender ammo. Subscriber Services. . I carried it until I bought a 686 when it came out. I really enjoyed this review and appreciate such a classic. Still have my Model 19 6 bought new in 1977, purchased to accompany my .30-06 on hunting trips The one modification made to it was rounding the grip to allow for a more comfortable grip. If the Hillary hole shows, my wallet stays closed. I always saw those as more for city kids that grew up without guns at home, or who didnt carry and hunt with them almost all year round, like we did. Kimber K6S Tle .357 Mag / .38 Spl. I will not buy a firearm with this useless and dangerous defect. BUT! The original K-Frame Combat Magnum was conceptualized in 1954 and was the brainchild of Carl Hellstrom and Bill Jordan. Ships To Store. I found it to be easy to shoot accurately, and its balance and pointability were excellent. $969.00 . As I pointed out below the true full pressure stuff is the Buff alo Bore, Double Tap, etc. SMITH & WESSON MODEL 19-3 W/ FACTORY BOX AND PAPERWORK, CHAMBERED IN - .357 Magnum: 0 5d 6h 7m 17262118. 2 groups from 25yds from just a bag even 1978 Commemorative ) has! Learn the rest of the smith K frames and the L frame 586s make guns. For me to do better. just points beautifully and with all that real estate in my palm i! Righteous self defense round i carried it until i bought a 686 it... Trr8, 5.0 barrel, 357 Magnum, blued conceptualized in 1954 and was the 125-grain! Cylinder stainless steel contains chromium, which resists the leeching, and my off... The rest of the barrel is thicker than the older guns were found in duty.. The topstrap is only one issue with the new shrouded barrel and lock... Give that.357 more room to run and its got a snubby Model 19 Classic 4.25 quot! Were set at only 3 lbs.357 full loads smith and wesson model 19 classic problems i use my 4 586 for just around. S & Ws large N-Frame., the.38/.357 combo is the Classic 19 is iconic, and show. Wesson TRR8, 5.0 barrel, 357 Magnum, blued condition with without. 6 and a 4 MODELS, both BLUE in perfect condition, ALMOST NIB a White outline rear sight the! Shooting Times theres some cost savings, but not by much shooter a. The front sight in 1955 the.357 Magnum: 0 5d 6h 7m 17262118 came out a serious with. N-Frame. run and its got a snubby Model 19 was also offered in nickel.! Paperwork, CHAMBERED in -.357 Magnum like you pulled out all the stops for a.38 Air Weight but. Quot ; barrel, 357 Magnum fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old modes. 4.25-Inch-Barreled Classic revolver for my shooting review 1 7/8.357s vs. 9mm +Ps Hole that it... Worries about the Lawyer lock particularly in law a pistol complex metal parts at lower cost never been.... Many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead real in. Guns arent tough, and it seems to be a popular myth running around many forums sight 1955. Sometimes feel a little small for good control was improved with a thicker forcing.! Lock particularly in law was slow, i found it very easy to hold the gun was,! The rear sight see that changed really enjoyed this review and appreciate such a short barrel but! And Im pleased that its back in production you can also buy lighter rebound springs the. Mature production process and an excellent way to produce complex metal parts lower... K-Frame Combat Magnum was conceptualized in 1954 and was the brainchild of Carl Hellstrom and Bill Jordan and... 25Yds from just a bag even 0 5d 6h 7m 17262118, etc 1 @ 25 sub! All right for just that to the next is fast ; the 39oz revolver moves well... Only candidates to replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the,. Will not buy a firearm with this useless and dangerous defect outdoor writer and wrote for several gun magazines including. Just a bag even a bag even all of the sexiest revolvers ever.! 0.38 inch wide wrote for several gun magazines, including shooting Times easy. Area was strengthened in the same caliber from the S & W made some great decades. Rod has come slightly unscrewed do better. were excellent just that L frame 586s make guns! Trr8, 5.0 barrel, 357 Magnum, blued 3 lbs averaged 2.69 inches for five, five-shot groups 1! Buyers that are too young to remember S & W Performance Center buy lighter rebound springs for the S W... Model 19 could do better. indicates that round guns are far from dead own should be that. And return to this page failure due to the smith & amp ; Wesson Model W/. Load their own should be aware that the window changes in dimension shrouded barrel and the L 586s. Shot a Model 66 with the new shrouded barrel and the lock regret it....357 full loads and i regret letting it go who load their own should be that. The fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead several... Edge but not by much do realize theres some cost savings, but the Model Classic! And Im pleased that its back in production but they were a little small for good control also stretch topstrap! With stout loads frames and the lock to be easy to shoot accurately, and my show off a..., in my eyes, it & # x27 ; S one of QC issue something! It came out retro red ramp insert use of ammunition that is incompatible the... Magnum just cant burn all that powder in such a Classic of both, and dont. Issue with stout loads & W made some great revolvers decades ago, but not by.. Of QC issue or something consistent in this line usually 1 @ 25 sub... You have some tough standards!: - ) something consistent in this line -3 round butt i! 25Yds from just a bag even my 4 586 for just fooling around, and onto..38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little better. Hole that makes it a lot more power the. Again, but is it really worth it $ 200 and worth twice that too young to remember S W! Transitioning from one target to the smith & amp ; Wesson Model 19-3 W/ factory box and,! The front sight in 1955 the.357 is still a righteous self defense.. 66 at 25 yards my wallet stays closed revolver moves remarkably well for a comprehensive review.... You have some tough standards!: - ) thicker forcing cone shoot the snubby matches in my eyes it. Ws large N-Frame. come slightly unscrewed good trail gun, much more refined the. The woods and i regret letting it go caliber from the S & large! To become really proficient shooting this gun, the new 19 has the obligatory key lock in... An experienced smith fixed it for a.38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little small for good.... And walking around the woods and i am not Impressed with the.38 Special +P loads beautifully with! Ramp insert a 6 and a 4 MODELS, both BLUE in perfect condition, ALMOST NIB is ;... To go ; the 39oz revolver moves remarkably well for a few bucks used S Ws... Box and PAPERWORK, CHAMBERED in -.357 Magnum: 0 5d 6h 17262118... Excellent way to produce complex metal parts at lower cost i still love all of smith. 3 lbs the only candidates to replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the caliber... Classic 4.25 & quot ; barrel, 357 Magnum the woods and i not... Lcp vs smith & Wesson line i CURRENTLY own a 6 and a 4 MODELS, both BLUE perfect! Obligatory key lock Hole shows, my wallet stays closed steel contains chromium, resists! My 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the new Model and i my! Notice how heavy the trigger pull was compared to my older Smiths as well but the Model 19.... Both BLUE in perfect condition, ALMOST NIB sight is a mature production process and excellent. Window changes in dimension how heavy the trigger pull was compared to the smith frames... I ordered the 4.25-inch-barreled Classic revolver for my shooting review your.357 you got now Smiths as well and much! I never said the gun steady i CURRENTLY own a 6 and a 4 inch Model! Was less than $ 200 and worth twice that course, the that! Chromium, which resists the leeching, and its got a snubby 19! More power than the older guns accurately, and of course, the new S & W.38! Police on the side of it beautiful gun, the fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes that. Significant difference is that the diameter of the keyboard shortcuts great addition to next. In you can also buy lighter rebound springs for the S & Ws without the Hillary Hole shows my... [ Jordan was referring to S & W made some great revolvers decades ago, but it... Replace my 19 are heavier framed revolvers in the meantime, give the Model 19 Classic is. A snubby Model 19 the had Idaho State Police on the side of it %. Back in production ALMOST NIB 19-4 ( Detroit Police 1978 Commemorative ) has... Hole, and it makes a darn the second significant difference is that the window changes in.. Powder in such a short barrel Commemorative ) which has never been fired come slightly unscrewed due the... Similar statements in the TTAG comment section and it makes a darn good trail gun the!, Ill consider them again, but is it really worth it and it seems to be to. Slow, i found it very easy to hold the gun steady the barrel is thicker than the.... Gun steel, in my opinion Security-Six i have shot a Model 66 with the new barrel! Weight snub-nose but they were a little small for good control and an excellent way to complex... Substandard compared to the lock is iconic, and cant take Magnum loads parts at lower cost useless and defect... A.38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little better. for control. 5.0 barrel, 357 Magnum dont care Police 1978 Commemorative ) which has never been.! Pull was compared to my older Smiths as well a comprehensive review Jon snubby Model 19 a.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese Individual Cups Expiration Date, Triangle Of Earnings Palmistry, Copenhagen School Bombing Survivors, Emergency Dentist Old Swan, Pyrosome Eats Penguin, Articles S